S. Ecthelion m. “?One with Sharp Will”

S. Ecthelion, m. “?One with Sharp Will”

An Elf-lord of Gondolin said to be “of the Fountain” (S/239), as well as 17th and 25th ruling stewards of Gondor (LotR/1039). This name is derived from the archaic form Ægthelion (WJ/318), and appears to be a combination of aeg “sharp”, a form of thel- “to resolve, will” and the masculine suffix -on¹, perhaps meaning “One with Sharp Will” (as suggested by David Salo, GS/339).

Conceptual Development: This Elf-lord was already called G. Ecthelion in the earliest Lost Tales (LT2/173), but the meaning of his name changed as Tolkien revised his conception of the Elvish languages. In the Gnomish Lexicon from the 1910s, his name was glossed “Lord of the Fountain”, from G. ecthel(uin) “fountain” (GL/31, LT2A/Ecthelion). In The Etymologies from the 1930s, N. Ecthelion was derived from ecthel, whose gloss is unclear but may mean “?point (of spear)”, as suggested by Christopher Tolkien (Ety/STELEG). The Sindarin derivation above appeared in very late notes on the Silmarillion from around 1970 (WJ/316, 318).

References ✧ LotR/1116; LotRI; LT1I; PMI; SI; UTI; WJ/318; WJI

Variations

Related

Elements

#aeg “sharp”
thel- “to intend, mean, purpose, resolve, will”
-on¹ “masculine suffix”
STEL “remain firm” ✧ WJ/318

N. Ecthelion m.

See S. Ecthelion for discussion.

References ✧ Ety/EK, STELEG; LRI; SMI; WRI

Variations

Elements

ecthel “?point (of spear)” ✧ Ety/STELEG
-ion¹ “son”
êg “thorn” ✧ Ety/EK
ᴹ√STELEG ✧ Ety/EK

G. Ecthelion m. “Lord of the Fountain”

References ✧ GL/31; LT2A/Ecthelion; LT2I; PE13/104; PE15/23

Glosses

Related

Elements

ecthel(uin) “fountain, fount” ✧ LT2A/Ecthelion (ecthel); PE15/23 (Ecthel)

Cognates