S. long voiceless spirants shortened; [θθ|xx] > [θ|x]
In both Sindarin and Noldorin, long voiceless spirants shortened, as noted by David Salo (GS/§4.184). Tolkien alluded to this phonetic development in a discussion of the transcriptions used by Ælfwine in his document on the Feanorian Alphabet from the 1930s:
The transcription used by Ælfwine, based mainly on Old English, and partly on Irish use, was variable ... These he represented thus: 3 by þ, ð (not initially) or th. Medially where Old English had not in his time a voiceless [þ] normally, he often used th, or even þþ, although the sound in Noldorin was never long in his time. e by f, ph. Medially where OE had not normally [f], he often used ph or ff, although [f] was never long in Noldorin in his time (PE22/033).
Based on this note, it seems all long spirants shortened in Noldorin: [θθ] > [θ], [xx] > [x], [ff] > [f]. There are examples of each of these phonetic developments in The Etymologies:
In Sindarin, however, it seems medial [ff] remained long:
PH ... in the middle of a few words where it represents a long ff (from pp) as in Ephel “outer fence” (LotR/1114).
The reduction of other long spirants was an aspect of Sindarin’s phonetic history, however. For example, S. roch had the same etymology as in Noldorin, and Tolkien explicitly described [θθ] > [θ] for Sindarin:
Of this already in Common Eldarin a diminutive/affectionate form was made with (as frequent in such words) reduplication of medial consonant > netthi. Of this Q. nette, T. nette, S. neth are normal developments (tth > Q., T., prehistoric S. tt; later S. þþ > þ) (VT47/14).
Conceptual Developments: Gnomish had the same reduction of long voiceless spirants, as noted by Roman Rausch in his Historical Phonology of Goldogrin (HGP/§2.4):
The same is true of Early Noldorin, as noted by Roman Rausch in his Historical Phonologies of Ilkorin, Telerin and Noldorin around 1923 (HPITN/§4.1.5), though finding a complete set of examples is challenging:
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
|
> |
|
✧ VT47/14 (þþ > þ); VT47/16 (þþ > þ) |
|
|
> |
|
Phonetic Rule Examples
| axx > ax | xx > x | √AKAS > aks > S. ach | ✧ PE17/92 |
| exxad- > exad- | xx > x | ✶et-kat- > S. echad- | ✧ PE17/42 |
| exxant > exant | xx > x | ✶et-kantē > S. echant | ✧ PE17/42 |
| roxx > rox | xx > x | ✶rokkō > S. roch | ✧ Let/282 |
| -aθθ > -aθ | θθ > θ | ✶atta > S. -ath | ✧ VT48/19 |
| aθθra- > aθra- | θθ > θ | ✶atta- > S. athra | ✧ PE17/14 |
| boθθ > boθ | θθ > θ | √MOT > mbotto > S. both | ✧ PE17/165 |
| -eθθ > -eθ | θθ > θ | ✶-ittā > S. -eth | ✧ PM/345 |
| groθθ > groθ | θθ > θ | ✶grottā > S. groth | ✧ WJ/415 |
| hoθθ > hoθ | θθ > θ | ✶khottă > S. hoth | ✧ PE17/39 |
| lebeθθron > lebeθron | θθ > θ | ✶lepeth-ron > S. lebethron | ✧ PE17/89 |
| loθθ > loθ | θθ > θ | √LOT > S. loth | ✧ PE17/161 |
| loθθ > loθ | θθ > θ | ✶lotse > S. loth | ✧ VT42/18 |
| loθθ > loθ | θθ > θ | ✶lotta- > S. loth | ✧ VT42/18 |
| morgoθθ > morgoθ | θθ > θ | ✶Moringotto > S. Morgoth | ✧ MR/194 |
| neθθ > neθ | θθ > θ | √NETH > S. neth | ✧ VT47/14 |
| neθθ > neθ | θθ > θ | ✶netthi > S. neth | ✧ VT47/33 |
| neθθ > neθ | θθ > θ | √net > S. neth | ✧ VT47/33 |
| nogoθθ > nogoθ | θθ > θ | ✶nukotto/a > S. Nogoth | ✧ WJ/413 |
| oθθui > oθui | θθ > θ | ✶otsōyā > S. othui | ✧ VT42/25 |
| peθθ > peθ | θθ > θ | √QUET > S. peth | ✧ PE17/46 |
| raθθ > raθ | θθ > θ | ✶ratta > S. rath | ✧ NM/364 |
| reθθ > reθ | θθ > θ | √RETE > S. -reth | ✧ PE17/182 |
| -roθθ > -roθ | θθ > θ | √ROT > S. -roth/rod | ✧ PE17/49 |
N. long voiceless spirants shortened; [ff|θθ|xx] > [f|θ|x]
Reference ✧ PE22/33
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
|
> |
|
|
|
|
> |
|
|
|
|
> |
|
Phonetic Rule Examples
| affarx > afarx | ff > f | ON. appharkha > N. afarch | ✧ EtyAC/A |
| effel > efel | ff > f | ᴹ✶Et-pele > eppele > N. Ephel | ✧ WR/137 |
| exx > ex | xx > x | ᴹ√EK > N. ech | ✧ Ety/EK |
| exxad- > exad- | xx > x | ᴹ✶et-kat > N. echedi | ✧ Ety/KAT |
| exxui > exui | xx > x | ᴹ✶et-kuiwē > N. echui(w) | ✧ Ety/KUY |
| l̥oxx > l̥ox | xx > x | ᴹ✶lokko > N. lhoch | ✧ Ety/LOKH |
| roxx > rox | xx > x | ᴹ✶rokkō > N. roch | ✧ EtyAC/ROK |
| -aθθ > -aθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶-atta > N. -ath | ✧ PE21/57 |
| aθθ- > aθ- | θθ > θ | ᴹ√AT(AT) > N. ath- | ✧ Ety/RAT |
| baθθa- > baθa- | θθ > θ | ON. batthṓ > N. batho | ✧ Ety/BAT |
| bereθθ > bereθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√MBER > N. bereth | ✧ Ety/MBER |
| dalaθθ > dalaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√DAL > N. dalath | ✧ Ety/DAL |
| daθθ > daθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶dattā > N. dath | ✧ Ety/DAT |
| eθθir > eθir | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶etsiri > N. ethir | ✧ Ety/ET |
| gaθθ > gaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶gattā > N. gath | ✧ Ety/GAT(H) |
| groθθ > groθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√ROT > N. groth | ✧ EtyAC/ROT |
| gwanaθθ > gwanaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√WAN > N. gwanath | ✧ Ety/WAN |
| gwaθθ > gwaθ | θθ > θ | ON. watte > N. gwath | ✧ Ety/WAƷ |
| gwaθθa- > gwaθa- | θθ > θ | ON. wattóbe > N. gwatho | ✧ Ety/WAƷ |
| gwiliθθ > gwiliθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√WIL > N. gwilith | ✧ Ety/WIL |
| gwilwileθθ > gwilwileθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√WIL > N. gwilwileth | ✧ Ety/WIL |
| hadlaθθ > hadlaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√KHAT > hadlath > N. haglath | ✧ Ety/KHAT |
| hadlaθθ > hadlaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√LATH/LAT > hadlath > N. haglath | ✧ Ety/LATH |
| halaθθ > halaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√SKAL > N. ?halath | ✧ EtyAC/SKEL |
| halaθθ > halaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√SKAL > N. heleth | ✧ EtyAC/SKEL |
| haθθel > haθel | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶syatsē̆la > N. hathel | ✧ Ety/SYAD |
| helaθθ > helaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√SKEL > N. helath | ✧ EtyAC/SKEL |
| heleθθ > heleθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√SKEL > N. heleth | ✧ Ety/SKEL |
| hoθθ > hoθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶khotsē > N. hoth | ✧ Ety/KHOTH |
| jaθθ > jaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶yatta > N. iath | ✧ EtyAC/YAT |
| keleθθ > keleθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√KEL > N. celeth | ✧ EtyAC/KEL |
| koθθ > koθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶kotse > N. coth | ✧ EtyAC/KOT |
| l̥aθθ > l̥aθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√LATH/LAT > N. lhath | ✧ Ety/LATH |
| liθθ > liθ | θθ > θ | ON. litthe > N. lith | ✧ Ety/LIT |
| maθθa- > maθa- | θθ > θ | ON. matthṓ-be > N. matho | ✧ Ety/MAƷ |
| meleθθ > meleθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√MEL > N. meleth | ✧ Ety/MEL |
| mereθθ > mereθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√MER > N. mereth | ✧ Ety/MBER |
| meθθ > meθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶metta > N. meth | ✧ Ety/MET |
| boθθ > moθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√MBOTH > N. both | ✧ Ety/MBOTH |
| naiθθ > naiθ | θθ > θ | ‽ᴹ✶natsai > N. naith | ✧ Ety/SNAS |
| naneθθ > naneθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√NAN > N. naneth | ✧ Ety/NAN |
| naθθ > naθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√SNAT > ‽ᴹ✶natsai | ✧ Ety/SNAS |
| naθθ > naθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√NAT > N. nath | ✧ Ety/NAT |
| neθθ > neθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√NETH > N. Neth | ✧ Ety/Nι |
| niθθ > niθ | θθ > θ | ON. nitse > N. nĭth | ✧ PE22/37 |
| palaθθ > palaθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√PAL > N. palath | ✧ Ety/PAL |
| paθθ > paθ | θθ > θ | ON. pattha > N. path | ✧ Ety/PATH |
| peθθ > peθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶kwetta > N. peth | ✧ Ety/KWET |
| raθθ > raθ | θθ > θ | ON. rattha > N. rath | ✧ Ety/RAT |
| roθθ > roθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ√ROT > N. roth | ✧ EtyAC/ROT |
| seθθ > seθ | θθ > θ | ᴹ✶settā > N. seth | ✧ EtyAC/SET |
| tiθθen > tiθen | θθ > θ | ᴹ√TIT > N. tithen | ✧ Ety/TIT |
| tiθθin > tiθin | θθ > θ | ᴹ√TIT > N. tithin | ✧ Ety/TIT |
G. long voiceless spirants shortened; [ff|θθ|xx] > [f|θ|x]
Phonetic Rule Elements
|
|
> |
|
|
|
|
> |
|
|
|
|
> |
|
Phonetic Rule Examples
| axx > ax | xx > x | ᴱ√aki > G. ach | ✧ GL/17 |
| krexx > krex | xx > x | ᴱ√kerek- > G. crech | ✧ GL/27 |
| uxx > ux | xx > x | ᴱ✶ukko > G. uch | ✧ GL/74 |
| blaθθ > blaθ | θθ > θ | ᴱ√PALA > G. blath | ✧ LT1A/Palúrien |
| gaθθ > gaθ | θθ > θ | ᴱ✶yatt- > G. gath¹ | ✧ GL/36 |
| goθθa- > goθa- | θθ > θ | ᴱ✶ı̯otta > G. gôtha- | ✧ GL/42 |
| heθθeglon > heθeglon | θθ > θ | ᴱ✶heth·thed·’lon > G. hetheglon | ✧ GL/49 |
| kuiθθ > kuiθ | θθ > θ | ᴱ√KOYO > G. cuith | ✧ LT1A/Koivië-néni |
| kʷeθθ > kʷeθ | θθ > θ | ᴱ√QETE > G. cweth | ✧ LT2A/Tôn a Gwedrin |
| mbriθθ- > mbriθ- | θθ > θ | ᴱ√M(B)ṚTṚ > G. brith- | ✧ QL/63 |
| -θθ > -θ | θθ > θ | G. -tt > G. -th | ✧ GG/10 |